March 20, 2023

Puttanesca Bread Dipping Oil

Jammy and sweet tomato confit, briny capers and olives, salty anchovies, all covered in EVOO, this Puttanesca Bread Dipping Oil is SCREAMING for some crusty bread.

Have you ever gone to an Italian restaurant and gotten bread dipping oil? You know that little dish of good EVOO and MAYBE a splash of balsamic vinegar or a tsp of some dry Italian herbs. Well this is that… but better. This puttanesca bread dipping oil has all the briny and salty familiar flavors that you love in a puttanesca sauce, but for a crusty loaf of bread. Perfect for a gathering or date night, but honestly if you want to eat this solo, been there, done that. So grab some crusty bread and start dipping.


The term confit is a traditional French cooking method that simply means to slow cook something submerged in fat or oil. Similarly to garlic confit, tomato confit is slow cooked tomatoes in olive oil. While I am calling these tomatoes a confit, we are actually not cooking them for multiple hours in this recipe… because we really don’t have time for that. The results are still the same, softened, super sweet tomatoes, and a umami packed olive oil perfect for this dipping oil. For this specific recipe all you need is tomatoes and olive oil, however the possibilities are endless when it comes to making tomato confit. Add in your favorite herbs or garlic to add another dimension of flavor.

Just like garlic confit, storing and food safety is critical. If you are consuming this immediately, then no worries. However If you are prepping the tomatoes in advance just beware that poor storage and handling can lead to botulism. Due to the PH level of tomatoes (same with garlic) there is not enough acid to prevent botulism. If prepping in advance let the tomatoes cool down and then transfer them to a clean airtight container, and place it in the refrigerator. NEVER store at room temperature, I can’t express this enough. While studies have shown that it is probably safe to consume within 7 days, best bet is don’t let it go over 3.

finished tomato confit in a bowl


puttanesca bread dipping oil


  • Cherry Tomatoes -Cherry tomatoes on the vine are my favorite to use, however might be harder to come by off season. Grape tomatoes are a great substitute and are available in most super markets year round.
  • Anchovies – I love anchovies, frankly I eat them straight out of the tin. If you hate anchovies because of the tiny hairline bones that are sometimes present, spend more on the tin. I have learned over the past few years, the higher quality anchovy the less hairlike bones you will get. My favorite brands are Delallo and Fishwife.
  • Kalamata Olives – Rough chopped or smashed.
  • Capers– Drained.
  • Olive Oil – Regular olive oil is fine to use for the tomato confit. If you need more olive oil to top the final dipping oil feel free to top it off with EVOO.


Confit the Tomatoes – Preheat your oven to 375F degrees. In a small ramekin, croquette, or another small oven safe dish add your cherry tomatoes. Fill the container 3/4 of the way with extra virgin olive oil and pop it in the oven for about 30 minutes. The tomatoes will have burst opened and softened. It is SO important to not fill the entire container up with olive oil to avoid a potential oven disaster. Also tip of advice, put your container on a sheet pan just in case the oil does bubble over.

Assemble – Quantity of ingredients is completely up to you depending on how many people you are serving. With that said you want this to be chunky, more toppings than olive oil. My suggestion for 2-3 people is 10 oz of tomatoes, and 2-3 tbsp of each of the additional ingredients. In a bowl add confit tomatoes, minced anchovies, smashed kalamata olives, capers, and top with the tomato confit oil. If you need more oil feel free to top it off with some more EVOO.


While this is a super easy recipe to pull together on a whim it is also a great one to prep in advance. The tomato confit can be made 1-2 days in advance, when ready to whip it all together place the tomatoes in the olive oil on the stove on low heat. Once warm add it to a bowl the with remainder of the ingredients. I don’t suggest you store leftovers, considering you will be multi dipping.

March 20, 2023

Puttanesca Bread Dipping Oil

Print Recipe Pin Recipe
All the familiar flavors in pasta puttanesca, but in a bread dipping oil.
Course Appetizer
Cuisine Italian
Keyword Bread Dipping Oil, Mezze, Tapas
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 30 minutes
Total Time 45 minutes
Servings 3 people


  • 10 oz cherry tomatoes or substitute with grape tomatoes.
  • 2 tbsp capers
  • 1-2 tbsp anchovies minced
  • 2-3 tbsp kalamata olives crushed or rough chopped
  • olive oil


Tomato Confit

  • Preheat your oven to 375°F degrees.
  • In a small ramekin, croquette, or another small oven safe dish add your cherry tomatoes. Fill the container 3/4 of the way with olive oil and pop it in the oven for about 30 minutes. *a good tip is to place the container on a sheet pan in case it overflows.


  • Once cooled add the tomatoes, capers, kalamata olives, anchovies, and tomato confit olive oil + juices to a low bowl. If you need to top it off with additional EVOO. Serve with crusty bread.

RATE + REVIEW What did you think of this recipe?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating